EAT on 15th September 2006, reported at [2007] ICR 135 (also reported at [2007] IRLR 198).


NOTES

  • Chairman & Governors of Amwell View School v Dogherty EAT on 15th September 2006 reported at [2007] ICR 135 (also reported at [2007] IRLR 198).
  • The full text of this judgment is available free of charge on the BAILII website
  • The full ICR report, including the judgment, is available from emplaw - click here for details (professional versions only)

    Authority for the proposition that:-

    1. an unauthorised or "clandestine" electronic recording made by an employee at a disciplinary panel hearing and subsequent appeal can be used as evidence in an Employment Tribunal hearing for unfair dismissal, provided of course it is relevant to the issue between the parties, except to the extent that it is a recording of the private deliberations of the panel;
    2. failure to maintain respect for the privacy of private deliberations would be contrary to the public interest as it would inhibit panel members from entering into open discussion and could give rise to satellite litigation based on leaks of the recordings.

    For relevant general notes see Procedure of Employment Tribunals/admissibility of evidence and see also Bills before Parliament/Interception of Communications (Admissibility of Evidence) Bill .


    FINISH>
    prepared Sept2006